Factory Farming: The Contagion of Free Trade

by Vandana Shiva

www.globalresearch.ca    20 March 2004

The URL of this article is: http://globalresearch.ca/articles/SHI403A.html


New diseases in animals are emerging and more virulent forms of old diseases are increasing. Epidemics are an intrinsic part of factory farming and industrial agriculture.

In the UK more than two million cattle were found to be infected with Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) - mad cow disease. By August 2002, 133 people had died from the Variant Creutzfeld-Jacob Disease (VCJD) - the human equivalent of BSE.

In 2001, an epidemic of foot-and-mouth disease in the UK led to the slaughter of more than five million animals, costing the government two billion pounds in direct payment to farmers alone.

The swine fever in Asia led to the killing of millions of pigs. A newly-emerged nipah strain killed 100 pig farm workers, infected 150 with non-fatal encephalitis and led to the slaughter of a million pigs to control the disease.

The avian flu has already led to human deaths and the killing of millions of ducks and chickens. Though the epidemic has abated, it has spread to 10 countries.

The avian flu has led to a ban on poultry imports - a ban that was removed as a result of WTO free trade rules. While the US has used the power of its giant corporations to force countries to open their markets to its exports, one mad cow case in the US was enough to interrupt its beef exports.

The avian flu has forced a reversal of the removal of Quantitative Restrictions (QRs) forced on India in 2000 as a result of a US-initiated dispute in WTO.

On April 1, 2001, India removed completely the QRs on imports of 1,429 items as per the bilateral agreement with the US. QRs on imports in respect of 714 items have already been removed with effect from April 1, 2000 .

QRs are the only real safeguards against public health risks. According to the commitment given by India to the developed world, we had till 2003 to remove all QRs.

This commitment had been accepted by countries of the European Union, Japan, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Switzerland. Yet India entered into a bilateral agreement with the US on December 28, 1999, which hastened the removal.

In December, 1999, the ministry of commerce worked out a deal with the US to remove QRs from 1,429 items.

Despite knowing how severe the impact of the removal of restrictions on imports would be, the Indian government asked Washington to announce this so-called "agreement" only after Parliament went with recess.

According to the Financial Times, the government feared that the sensitive matter could be used by law-makers eager to make political capital.

The announcement of the bilateral agreement was finally made on December 28, 1999 by US trade representative Charlene Barshefsky, who applauded it, saying: "I am pleased that we have reached an agreement that is mutually beneficial to both the United States and to India. Eliminating these restrictions will provide - for the first time in 50 years for some products - market access opportunities for US producers in key sectors such as textiles, agriculture, consumer goods and a wide variety of manufactured products..."

The flooding of Indian markets with these products whose import was restricted to conserve scarce foreign exchange, and protect jobs and livelihoods, will have a devastating impact on the Indian people and the economy.

Most items in the restricted list are agricultural products, items produced in the small-scale household sector and animal products. Among the unrestricted imports are carcasses and animal waste parts that could be a threat to our public health.

It also includes fish, milk, coconut, coffee, spices, tea, ragi, bajra, neem products and even Basmati. This flood of imports will leave no aspect of the Indian economy untouched.

The reintroduction of QRs on chicken imports due to the avian flu indicates that it needs to be maintained for health security, ecological security and livelihood security.

Precaution must be the policy. And since factory farms have an established track record of spreading diseases, imports need to be governed on the basis of the precautionary principle.

We need to heed these warning signals and revisit the false assumption that deregulated commerce and free trade in food improves welfare. It is hurting both human and animal welfare.

Globalisation and free trade create the compulsion for factory farming and intensive agriculture, with increasing costs to the planet, animal welfare and public health.

Export- and trade-dominated agriculture demands monocultures. While production for local needs can be based on free range chicken and forage-fed cattle, production for trade creates captive production as more livestock are cooped together for industrial efficiency.

The result is ecological inefficiency and a recipe for the creation and spread of new diseases.

Industrial farming is a highly inefficient form of production when viewed from the perspective of animals and humans.

It is efficient only from the perspective of trade and industry which externalises all environmental and health costs and leaves the planet and people with the burden of pollution and disease.

According to data from the US itself, it takes 16 kg of grain to produce a kg of beef. The UK poultry industry states that it takes 1.6 kg of feed to produce one kg of animal meat of which only 33.7 per cent is edible.

In terms of the feed/food ratio, industrial farming is a negative economy which consumes more than is produced.

List of Articles
번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수 추천 수sort
공지 보도자료. 구타와 도살, 한국의 경마산업 최초 조사 영상 imagefile 관리자 2019-05-04 144434 1
공지 2018맹견등 시행령 시행규칙개정안 입법예고안 file 관리자 2018-12-10 123985  
공지 무허가축사적법화 이행기간 운영지침 imagefile 관리자 2018-02-22 130601  
공지 서울행정법원의 서울대학교병원 동물실험정보의 전면적 공개 판결을 환영한다. (보도자료, 성명서, 비교표 첨부) file 동물지킴이 2017-09-11 149115 1
공지 부처이관 참고자료 생학방 2017-06-04 173614  
공지 (긴급)동물보호법 교육프로그램 imagefile 동물지킴이 2016-12-17 151154  
공지 이정덕 교수님을 추모합니다 imagefile [2] 지킴이 2016-10-25 196106  
공지 2016 실험동물을 위한 희망프로젝트 imagefile [1] 관리자 2016-04-04 158327  
공지 비디오 시청: 조류독감: 우리가 자초하는 바이러스 생명체간사 2014-03-30 177162  
공지 2012년 생명체학대방지포럼 사업보고 imagefile 생명체간사 2013-01-01 195367  
공지 동물실험에 대한 수의학도의 증언 [3] 생명체간사 2012-02-20 205267 3
공지 7/22 목 포대에 남부대 홍교수님을 추천함 [2] 생학방간사 2010-03-06 257711 42
공지 동물보호법/조례소식은?( 2013년 10월 1일 심상정의원의원발의) 생학방 2009-09-25 214041 107
1813 채식정보 베지푸드 imagefile [1] rhgowj 2011-03-28 6424  
» 공장식사육에 대한 반대. 반다나 시바, (영문) [1] 생명체학대방지포럼 2011-03-29 27867  
1811 정부의 가축질병방역체계 개선및 축산업선진화방안 내용 생명체 간사 2011-03-26 4333  
1810 생매장 공개시사기자회견안내 생명체 간사 2011-02-22 5864  
1809 모든 생명과 자연 환경은 올바로 보호받아야 한다. JWJ 2011-02-27 5334  
1808 김효석의원 가축사육환경 개선내용 동물보호법 개정안 발의 image [1] 생명체 간사 2011-03-04 5631  
1807 SBS동물농장의 중국모피 동영상 UP! 언제 내려질지 모르니 빨리 보세요. 미키 2011-02-21 9532  
1806 정부의 축산선진화방안 발표 생명체 간사 2011-03-24 4614  
1805 기업축산이 식량안전을 위협한다.(영문) 생명체학대방지포럼 2011-03-29 6861  
1804 [미국 기사1] 억제가 어려운 애니멀 호더 미키 2011-04-04 7850  
1803 애니멀호딩(과잉다두사육)… 그 실태와 대책 [1] 미키 2011-04-04 7052  
1802 구제역을 통해본 자본주의시대의 환경과 생명 학술심포지움 4월 8일 생명체간사 2011-04-05 5709  
1801 애니멀 호더 (Animal hoarder)이란? 미키 2011-04-05 10970  
1800 [미국 기사2] 애니멀 호딩은 정신질환의 증상인 경우가 많다. [1] 미키 2011-04-07 7999  
1799 지구온난화 방지를 위한 2011' 제10회 국제 지구사랑 작품공모전 환경실천연합회 2011-04-14 6392  
1798 동물실험의 모순을 여실히 보여주는 제약회사 광고 imagefile [2] 김기왕 2011-04-25 8462  
1797 구제역 재난 진단과 과제 지킴이 2011-05-09 4494  
1796 (시민환경연구소 논평) 지속가능한 축산의 전기를 마련해야 지킴이 2011-05-09 5115  
1795 구제역에 관한 참고 연구 연구 자료 하나 [1] 김기왕 2011-05-11 4243  
1794 반려동물인 애완돼지 형통이를 좀 봐주세요*^.^* [1] 만사형통 2011-05-15 6254